Over the past couple of months I've taken to watching three shows on The Food Network: Diners, Drive-ins, and Dives (3D), Restaurant Impossible, and especially, Chopped.
These are not about food. Television is a poor medium for taste and smell, and in LED facsimile even color doesn't work to well. For me, at least, Pavlov's response is not triggered; the shows don't make me hungry.
Instead the programs are about restaurants: the people who work in them, the people who eat at them, the kinds of destinations they make, and what their business model is. Themes run the gamut, from a reality-show episode exposing a family torn asunder by their restaurant, to a sober account of how the front of the house should be managed. Food and recipes also appear, but are mostly relegated to the webpage.
When I was growing up, my parents had a friend--moneyed beyond his professor's salary--who fancied himself a connoisseur--fine art, classical music, good wine, elegant furniture, and excellent food. As a divorcee he did most of his own cooking, to Mozart accompaniment, but it was not his passionate avocation. His kitchen possessed a repertoire of tasteful, clever, well-engineered gadgets that supposedly made the job easier.
His facility was nothing compared to those I discovered in the pages of Architectural Digest. The kitchens of the 1% (a few of which I've actually seen in person) are vast, barn-like structures with every appliance imaginable, decorated with granite counter tops, built-in freezers, and possessed of mountain/ocean/city vistas. These are kitchens as a competitive sport--read David Brooks' funny account of the phenomenon in Bobos In Paradise.
So you will understand that for most of my life I thought of haute cuisine as the preserve of the well-to-do. My more humble family ate good food, but it was simple fare. In my college town there was exactly one Chinese restaurant, and otherwise one could choose between diners, the occasional steakhouse, or maybe a sandwich shop. McDonalds came of age during my youth. Needless to say, we didn't eat out often.
Imagine my surprise, then, when I saw the chefs on Chopped--tattooed, overweight, scraggly, working-class folks. Far from the kitchens of Architectural Digest, the Chopped contestants are the sons and daughters of truck drivers, plumbers, and maids. They're not listening to Mozart. The runner-up on today's episode was a ghetto kid who spent part of his life homeless, and then got a job as a dishwasher, feeding himself from the leftovers on people's plates. From that he worked his way up to chef--no formal education. The winner had a more stable life growing up in poor, East Los Angeles. Both of them are highly skilled, incredibly practiced cooks.
And likewise with the other programs. The chefs on 3D are one step removed from the short order cook at Dennys. And the owners profiled in Restaurant Impossible are former garbage handlers and postal employees. These are not people my parents' professor friend would associate with, nor did they grow up in an elite kitchen.
So what's changed? How has cooking gone from a hobby of the elite to a skill for the dispossessed?
I'll suggest three things. First on the list is WalMart. While a luxury kitchen is still a luxury, a perfectly functional kitchen can be had at everyday low prices. Even poor kids can obtain a blender, buy some decent knives and teflon pans, and have access to a stove, fridge and freezer. That's different from my youth, where much on that list were middle class appliances.
Second, improvements in transport and agriculture means that quality, fresh food can be had at almost any grocery store. Yes, there's a marginal benefit to Whole Foods or some other elite store, but those are no longer necessary. As Robert Irvine of Restaurant Impossible never tires of pointing out, fresh food is both cheaper and better than the frozen or canned variety. You don't need to be rich to buy it anymore.
And finally, as the above implies, we're all richer now. In contrast to where I grew up, the college town I live in now has three sushi bars, along with other places serving Thai, Indian, Chinese, Japanese, Italian, and American cuisine. All for a town of about 30,000 people! But food in my town is downright expensive compared to New York City, where you can eat like a king for under $15.
So why is this important? My Trotskyist friends will take these lower class chefs and lump them in with the proletariat--a term they consider complimentary. But it's really deeply insulting because it dismisses the hours and hours and hours of practice and hard work these people invested in their trade. Like the rest of us, the Chopped contestants all aspire to the petty bourgeoisie, i.e., they hope to bring some unique, marketable skill to the table. The proletariat has power and significance only in the abstract mass--the attributes of an individual don't matter much. Thus Trotskyists are championing the fast food strike, trying to extort higher wages for people whose jobs are already at risk of automation.
More serious is the opinion of Tyler Cowen in his book Average Is Over. He argues that while there will be more millionaires and billionaires than ever before, the largest part of the American population--85%--will be left behind. Those that succeed will have the cognitive chops to compete and cooperate with computers. But he's wrong.
The Chopped champs may be smart, but they've got a different kind of chops. Unlike any computer they can chop vegetables, reduce a broth, taste a sauce, and judge the color of meat. Very few of them will be millionaires, but most of them will earn a living. And unlike what Mr. Cowen claims, they'll do better than just feeding the Architectural Digest crowd (though they'll be doing that, too).
Everybody wants good food. All the food in my town is putting the old-fashioned diners out of business. The restaurants that specialize in prepackaged microwave food (e.g., Olive Garden) are probably next in line. Fast food places will be automated and their employees laid off.
People--even poor people--are going to be eating much better food in the future. The former fast food workers will find employment as servers and busboys in gourmet restaurants, run by Chopped champions who really know what they're doing. Their customers will be you and me--we'll get quality, fresh ingredients, combined in complex, tasty recipes, cooked by expert chefs, served by trained staff--and all for under $10.
Mr. Cowen is wrong. Automation will eliminate lots of jobs. But it will make better jobs just as quick, and it will make us all richer in the process. Yeah--McDonald's and (maybe) Starbucks will be automated, but their former employees won't be sitting around collecting welfare. They'll be creating yet more value added that improves the lives of everybody.
Is this a great country, or what?
Further Reading:
Thursday, October 24, 2013
Sunday, October 20, 2013
Unprecedented Times
There's the old Jewish joke:
The latest cause for panic--according to Brian Williams in this front page article-- is that Janet Yellen has been appointed Chair of the Federal Reserve. Why the cause for fright?
Here's Mr. Williams' argument:
I know Brian Williams well from my time in Chicago. We nicknamed him "Brainy" because he was pretty sharp. And his piece is well-written and as cogently argued as is possible for a Marxist. But at the end of the day, it's just wrong.
We live in precedented times.
Further Reading:
We live in unprecedented times! Why, there are people dying today who've never died before.It is precisely this kind of precedent that The Militant twists into the latest crisis. Not for them is the normal warp and woof of daily life. Instead, every event, however trivially novel, is an argument for the end of life as we know it.
The latest cause for panic--according to Brian Williams in this front page article-- is that Janet Yellen has been appointed Chair of the Federal Reserve. Why the cause for fright?
Here's Mr. Williams' argument:
- The economy is doing poorly.
- As a result, unemployment is high.
- The Fed pretends to be fixing that.
- In reality, the Fed is just trying to maintain profit margins for the fat cats.
- What is really needed is a depression-era public works program that "actually put[s] millions to work building and repairing things workers need — at the expense of capitalists’ profits."
The Militant's case for a poor economy is pretty thin.
Yet all evidence points to the conclusion that the monetary fiddling has no effect on bosses’ hiring. The world crisis of capitalism is rooted in a slowdown of production and trade, which is not affected by government policies. Over the past year through mid-2013, world trade volume “has lost its mojo,” remaining virtually stagnant, reported the Financial Times.So there are many reasons why world trade could stagnate without necessarily indicating a bad economy. I'll cite two:
- North America is now a major oil and gas producer, resulting in diminished trade between our continent and the Middle East.
- Manufacturing is increasingly automated. Therefore there is less reason to move it offshore, and indeed, ever more reason to bring it back home. America's booming textile industry is an example of that. This reduces shipping costs.
Production isn't slowing down. It is just becoming cheaper, and therefore more of it is being done locally. This is not an indicator of a weak economy.
So then why is unemployment so high? Actually unemployment really isn't all that high--in August, 2013, it was 7.3%. But Mr. Williams is correct that most of the recent decline is due to shrinking of the labor force rather than a recovery of the economy. In other words, more and more people are dropping out of work.
That is not good news no matter how you spin it. But is it due to economic weakness or to some other factors? That's a matter of much debate, but I side with the folks who suggest other factors, also known as a structural change in the economy. Jobs that used to exist (e.g., lawyers) are being rapidly automated, and the biggest effect of the 2007-08 recession was to speed up that automation. That means that workers' skill sets no longer match what the economy requires. Jobs as a laborer on an assembly line don't exist anymore, and people who used to earn a living doing that are either unemployed, or earning substantially lower wages.
Couple that with excessive government regulations, and low wage work is rapidly becoming uneconomic. Between minimum wage, payroll taxes, new Obamacare regulations, and various licensing requirements, hiring somebody for less than $10/hour doesn't make much sense. Briefly, a large number of people can no longer earn enough to keep them in the labor force.
That means Mr. Williams is right to say that the Fed can't do much about unemployment. Monetary policy is effective for cyclical unemployment--and indeed, the reduction from 10% to the current value may very well be due to Fed actions. But structural unemployment is a different beast, and requires a much larger change in government policy and workers' skills.
So why is the Fed printing money? Gee, there are probably as many answers to that question as there are people. Mr. Williams (along with some at ZH) argue that they're in cahoots with the crony capitalists, such Goldman-Sachs and Chase-Manhattan. Maybe. There are others (e.g., Paul Krugman) who disagree with the structural change hypothesis and simply argue that the stimulus isn't big enough. ("Stimulus" and "Fed easing" are two different things, but Mr. Williams conflates them and I'll go along for the ride.)
Others argue that the Fed action is too small to be consequential--a theory at odds with the popularly used descriptor, mega-printing. My opinion is that production costs are relentlessly going down, and the result is a long-term deflationary trend. The Fed is doing its best to keep nominal prices approximately constant.
Whatever. Outside of the ZH world and Mr. Williams' imagination, none of these models imply that the Fed is building a crisis for the future. We are not in an economic crisis.
So we come to Mr. Williams' proposed solution to the non-crisis--a massive, depression-era public works program. Doing what, exactly? Back in the 1930s men still built roads with picks and shovels. Today one worker can do the job previously done by dozens. We've got two such make-work projects here on my own campus--construction of new academic buildings--both at union scale. The one now under construction probably never has more than 30 guys working on site at any one time.
The problem with these infrastructure, welfare projects is not only do they waste money, but they don't employ very many people. And worse--they are not going to employ the structurally unemployed. The number of unskilled laborers required at today's construction sites is pretty small. And people with skills already have jobs--they don't need the welfare work.
Like most Marxists, Mr. Williams can't resist a slander of the financial markets. He says
But with the slowdown, it’s not profitable for the great majority of bosses to invest in equipment and labor to expand production. Instead, they mostly tend to sit on hoards of cash reserves or seek higher returns through investing it in stocks or other forms of speculative bets, such as on the rise or fall of various kinds of commercial paper.This plays to the Marxist conceit that Wall Street is just a casino. But it isn't--companies need capital in order to operate. That capital can come in two ways--equity or debt. Equity is sold through the stock market, and debt is acquired through "commercial paper." Investing in stocks or commercial paper is investing in the "equipment and labor to expand production." The rise of the stock market is, in fact, a very good indicator that the economy is doing fine.
I know Brian Williams well from my time in Chicago. We nicknamed him "Brainy" because he was pretty sharp. And his piece is well-written and as cogently argued as is possible for a Marxist. But at the end of the day, it's just wrong.
We live in precedented times.
Further Reading:
Tuesday, October 15, 2013
Book Review: Average Is Over
Tyler Cowen's recent book, Average Is Over, is a deeply pessimistic and fundamentally mistaken look at America's future. He's got the ingredients right--computerization, globalization, a skills misfit--but he puts them together in a way that doesn't make any sense.
No doubt we are beginning an era of rapid technological change, one probably as dramatic as the industrial revolution or electrification. The computer revolution has grown up, is leaving the IT ghetto behind, and now is moving into the world of Real Stuff, radically changing the way we will live. Many, many jobs will be automated out of existence, or at least changed into something unrecognizable today. This will involve a new way of working, putting a premium on different sets of work skills.
Mr. Cowen's book catalogs some of those changes, using, among other items, the interesting example of freestyle chess as a guide. Unlike the traditional mano a mano chess tournaments of yore, freestyle chess lets the players use whatever tools are available, including powerful computers (that Mr. Cowen dubs genius machines). The combination of man and machine is more effective than either alone, and the best freestyle chess teams can beat any human or computer opponent out there. Freestyle teams include computer geeks and chess nerds--but not the best of either. Instead, the teams put a premium on computer/human teamwork, and must decide when to trust the computer, or instead go with human instinct. This is a different skill set than either the traditional grandmaster or computer nerd possesses.
His discussion of chess occupies a goodly portion of the book, but two other examples add to the flavor. He spends most of a chapter on String Theory, an esoteric field of physics primarily of interest to hobbyists. Finally we come (sort of) down to earth with an account of the digestive tract in starfish.
So there you have it. You take these examples, add them together, and you get--I dunno--maybe $5-6 million in global annual revenue if you're lucky. Enough to keep Bill Gates in the pink for a couple of weeks, but this is not the stuff that economies are made of. While he does mention other topics of somewhat more practical importance, the book radiates unreality. There is very little about how people in the future will actually earn a living.
Indeed, in one large part of our economy he argues that the dashing young men and their genius machines will have almost no impact at all. By virtue of demographics, he predicts that health care costs will continue to grow faster than inflation indefinitely. I find this incredible. At most demographics suggests a growing job market for home health care aids (a low wage job), but surely the genius machines are going to displace large numbers of doctors and technicians. Watson (it of Jeopardy fame) was designed to do medical diagnoses--no human doctor will be able to compete with that. Radiologists, pathologists, oncologists, etc., are all looking at the unemployment line.
Indeed, I think Mr. Cowen gets the trend all wrong. He says that middle-wage workers (bookkeepers, travel agents, stock clerks) will suffer most, while the "cognitive elite" will benefit. But he's wrong. Computers are putting lots of lawyers out of work right now. College professors are on the bubble. Doctors are not too far behind. The cost savings is maximized when you eliminate the most expensive people. The home health care aid, nurse practitioner, and physical therapist are more likely to stay employed than most doctors. Those middle-income, skilled trades will survive and thrive--they're the eyes, hands and feet for the computers.
It is surely odd that Mr. Cowen has not addressed topics more central to the way people actually make money. Important topics such as agriculture, oil & gas, and manufacturing are almost unmentioned. And this leads to the fundamental flaw of the book.
He posits that the future will lead to a radically inegalitarian society, with a few very wealthy millionaires and billionaires, and the rest of us left over as shlubs. This seems indisputable, and inequality doesn't bother me particularly. But he further claims that a large fraction of our population will be poorer in an absolute sense, not just relatively. They will live in more isolated areas, have less access to health care, eat lower quality food, and live in smaller and less comfortable houses. I find this unbelievable. As I say, his is a very pessimistic view of the future. I also don't think it's true.
You can see why Mr. Cowen thinks so. Given that his examples are all of the pocket change variety, no wonder he thinks we'll all be poor. But then why are we undergoing this huge technological revolution just to save a few pennies at the margin? Mr. Cowen's (implicit) answer to that is very disturbing.
No doubt we are beginning an era of rapid technological change, one probably as dramatic as the industrial revolution or electrification. The computer revolution has grown up, is leaving the IT ghetto behind, and now is moving into the world of Real Stuff, radically changing the way we will live. Many, many jobs will be automated out of existence, or at least changed into something unrecognizable today. This will involve a new way of working, putting a premium on different sets of work skills.
Mr. Cowen's book catalogs some of those changes, using, among other items, the interesting example of freestyle chess as a guide. Unlike the traditional mano a mano chess tournaments of yore, freestyle chess lets the players use whatever tools are available, including powerful computers (that Mr. Cowen dubs genius machines). The combination of man and machine is more effective than either alone, and the best freestyle chess teams can beat any human or computer opponent out there. Freestyle teams include computer geeks and chess nerds--but not the best of either. Instead, the teams put a premium on computer/human teamwork, and must decide when to trust the computer, or instead go with human instinct. This is a different skill set than either the traditional grandmaster or computer nerd possesses.
His discussion of chess occupies a goodly portion of the book, but two other examples add to the flavor. He spends most of a chapter on String Theory, an esoteric field of physics primarily of interest to hobbyists. Finally we come (sort of) down to earth with an account of the digestive tract in starfish.
So there you have it. You take these examples, add them together, and you get--I dunno--maybe $5-6 million in global annual revenue if you're lucky. Enough to keep Bill Gates in the pink for a couple of weeks, but this is not the stuff that economies are made of. While he does mention other topics of somewhat more practical importance, the book radiates unreality. There is very little about how people in the future will actually earn a living.
Indeed, in one large part of our economy he argues that the dashing young men and their genius machines will have almost no impact at all. By virtue of demographics, he predicts that health care costs will continue to grow faster than inflation indefinitely. I find this incredible. At most demographics suggests a growing job market for home health care aids (a low wage job), but surely the genius machines are going to displace large numbers of doctors and technicians. Watson (it of Jeopardy fame) was designed to do medical diagnoses--no human doctor will be able to compete with that. Radiologists, pathologists, oncologists, etc., are all looking at the unemployment line.
Indeed, I think Mr. Cowen gets the trend all wrong. He says that middle-wage workers (bookkeepers, travel agents, stock clerks) will suffer most, while the "cognitive elite" will benefit. But he's wrong. Computers are putting lots of lawyers out of work right now. College professors are on the bubble. Doctors are not too far behind. The cost savings is maximized when you eliminate the most expensive people. The home health care aid, nurse practitioner, and physical therapist are more likely to stay employed than most doctors. Those middle-income, skilled trades will survive and thrive--they're the eyes, hands and feet for the computers.
It is surely odd that Mr. Cowen has not addressed topics more central to the way people actually make money. Important topics such as agriculture, oil & gas, and manufacturing are almost unmentioned. And this leads to the fundamental flaw of the book.
He posits that the future will lead to a radically inegalitarian society, with a few very wealthy millionaires and billionaires, and the rest of us left over as shlubs. This seems indisputable, and inequality doesn't bother me particularly. But he further claims that a large fraction of our population will be poorer in an absolute sense, not just relatively. They will live in more isolated areas, have less access to health care, eat lower quality food, and live in smaller and less comfortable houses. I find this unbelievable. As I say, his is a very pessimistic view of the future. I also don't think it's true.
You can see why Mr. Cowen thinks so. Given that his examples are all of the pocket change variety, no wonder he thinks we'll all be poor. But then why are we undergoing this huge technological revolution just to save a few pennies at the margin? Mr. Cowen's (implicit) answer to that is very disturbing.
His view of America's future is similar to Latin America's present--a wealthy elite lording it over the miserable peasants. But America isn't built that way. Unlike Latin America, our economy is not structured around crony capitalism (despite the best efforts of Democrats to move us in that direction). Rich people in the US can't just collect rents in the manner of Carlos Slim, Pemex, the Mexican teachers' unions, or the drug gangsters. Instead, American billionaires become rich only because they provide goods and services to consumers at prices people can afford.
Yes, we have a few, rent-collecting scoundrels--maybe Goldman Sachs falls into that category. But folks like Malcom McLean, Sam Walton, Steve Jobs, and George Mitchell all did something that made everybody richer. Mr. Cowen describes a scene--two billionaires having lunch--that shows he fails to appreciate this fact. Those two billionaires earned their billions by improving the lives of us shlubs--not by diminishing them.
There is no good way to interpret the message of Average is Over. Perhaps Mr. Cowen thinks we're going to evolve into a crony economy such as they have in Mexico, Brazil and Argentina? That is surely a very depressing thought, and one the Tea Party is actively resisting. If that's true then we really will become poorer, but it won't be because of technological change or the computer revolution.
Or perhaps Mr. Cowen thinks that billionaires can become rich without selling anything to anybody? In Average is Over, apparently the only things the peasants can buy is cheap entertainment. That's it--an economy based on Grand Theft Auto and internet porn. No wonder Mr. Cowen picks examples of no financial significance.
In reality, billionaires become rich because they sell things to people at a price we can afford. Us shlubs buy the stuff because it makes our lives better. Of course there will be winners and losers in any technological revolution--just ask lawyers, college professors and doctors about that. But Mr. Cowen's dire prediction of mass impoverishment will not come to pass.
My post entitled Getting Richer While Feeling Poorer is a much clearer vision of the future than Average is Over. Mr. Cowen exaggerates the problem of inequality, which I address in a post entitled Are Rich People Rich? Finally, some thoughts on the future of the labor market in STEM fields are here.
I've read a lot of books by Tyler Cowen and Alex Tabarrok. I have enjoyed them all, including this one. But within that set, the current tome is well below average.
Further Reading:
In reality, billionaires become rich because they sell things to people at a price we can afford. Us shlubs buy the stuff because it makes our lives better. Of course there will be winners and losers in any technological revolution--just ask lawyers, college professors and doctors about that. But Mr. Cowen's dire prediction of mass impoverishment will not come to pass.
My post entitled Getting Richer While Feeling Poorer is a much clearer vision of the future than Average is Over. Mr. Cowen exaggerates the problem of inequality, which I address in a post entitled Are Rich People Rich? Finally, some thoughts on the future of the labor market in STEM fields are here.
I've read a lot of books by Tyler Cowen and Alex Tabarrok. I have enjoyed them all, including this one. But within that set, the current tome is well below average.
Further Reading:
Sunday, October 13, 2013
College & Wishful Thinking
Here's a prediction for you:
Of course, by then we'll all be dead, so who cares.
For me, I'm 62, and I am emotionally invested in disrupting higher ed. It's got to happen quick--I certainly won't be around much more than 20 years and I want to see how it's all going to turn out. So in my heart I make the following prediction:
Not so for my colleague, Joe. He, about 40 years old, just got tenure, and accordingly is promised a 25 year future on our campus. My prediction renders that promise empty--it says he will rarely if ever get a raise, and tenured job security won't be what it's cracked up to be. Still, Joe might agree with my prediction. He'd just argue about the time frame--such dramatic change simply won't happen over a mere decade.
I want to out-live higher ed. Joe wants to live out his career in higher ed. What you think depends on where you sit.
There are people who share my judgement about the lack of social utility, but not my optimism. I'm thinking of Bryan Caplan, who like me, advocates taking tax dollars out of higher education. His view is that college is disproportionately a signaling phenomena. Students go to college to demonstrate to future employers that they are diligent, can follow directions, and have invested more in their careers than other people. There is relatively little human capital appreciation through college--it is mostly a zero-sum signaling game. Students pay a very high cost, investing years and tens of thousands of dollars just to show that their signal is better than some other students. Students and society are losers, while colleges and employers reap the benefits. (I think Tyler Cowan effectively rebuts the argument here.)
Closer to my view is Glenn Reynolds, of Instapundit. He keeps talking about the higher education bubble, though it's not immediately clear what that means. It sounds like college is a house of cards, ready to fall apart. But the revolutionary zeal is largely absent from his book, which mostly suggests some rather modest changes around the edges--certainly nothing as dramatic or on as short a time frame as I have proposed.
Mr. Caplan's pessimistic conclusion is that higher ed, however dysfunctional, is nevertheless stable and will not change quickly. We're stuck with the girl that brung us. Thus he disagrees with all the bubble/crisis talk, and won't find my ten-year deadline credible. He'd say I live in the land of wishful thinking.
Other futurologists suffer from wishful thinking. Famously, the climate science crowd fell for a typographical error. A prediction had it that the Himalayan glaciers would melt by 2350--well beyond my lifespan--but this was copied into an IPCC report as 2035. The new catastrophe was eagerly accepted by climatologists around the world--it took the Indian government to point out the obvious mistake.
Back when I was an 18-year-old Trotskyist, in response to questions about the timing of the world revolution, we answered "maybe twenty years from now." For me that was more than a lifetime--a very long time away. Our thesis was that, because of new technology, history was speeding up--we could expect change faster than before. Today it seems hopelessly unrealistic--if anything, now forty years later, the revolution is even further away than it ever was.
So I could be a wishful thinker, but I'll stick to my ten-year prediction for these reasons. First, colleges are already under significant stress, with increasing pressure to lower prices and costs. Second, however relevant the curriculum may have been in the 1990s and before, it is much less useful today. I'm thinking of the general chemistry class I teach--it made students employable back then, but much less so today. And third, there simply is more competition than before. Students just have more choices.
When do these incremental changes reach a tipping point and disrupt the whole system? Will MOOCs be the straw that breaks the camel's back? Will it result from the unbundling implicit in the accreditation of individual courses? I don't know. Tipping points are notoriously hard to predict.
But here I stand: college will tip over sometime within the next nine years, eleven months, and 29 days. And good riddance!
Further Reading:
In the future, higher education will be very different from what it is today.This seems almost trivially true, if only because the words future and different are left undefined. Certainly, by the year 2100, changes in technology, the economy, finances, and demographics will render higher education unrecognizable by today's academics.
Of course, by then we'll all be dead, so who cares.
For me, I'm 62, and I am emotionally invested in disrupting higher ed. It's got to happen quick--I certainly won't be around much more than 20 years and I want to see how it's all going to turn out. So in my heart I make the following prediction:
Over the next ten years, existing colleges and universities will lose their ability to control the curriculum. Instead, students will choose what they study and how they do it. Faculty will more and more be in competition with each other for students' patronage and attention. The very best faculty will earn an excellent living, but median salaries will decline and job security will disappear. By and large, faculty will be reduced to adjunct status.That's much more specific, and so hardly a slam-dunk prediction. There are two parts: the outcome itself, and the time frame in which it is supposed to happen. I'm pretty confident about the outcome, and much less certain on the ten years. I favor the outcome because it has much greater social utility than what we have now--students will get a better education at a significantly cheaper price. Of course, I'll be retired before it really hits the fan--it will have little or no impact on my career.
Not so for my colleague, Joe. He, about 40 years old, just got tenure, and accordingly is promised a 25 year future on our campus. My prediction renders that promise empty--it says he will rarely if ever get a raise, and tenured job security won't be what it's cracked up to be. Still, Joe might agree with my prediction. He'd just argue about the time frame--such dramatic change simply won't happen over a mere decade.
I want to out-live higher ed. Joe wants to live out his career in higher ed. What you think depends on where you sit.
There are people who share my judgement about the lack of social utility, but not my optimism. I'm thinking of Bryan Caplan, who like me, advocates taking tax dollars out of higher education. His view is that college is disproportionately a signaling phenomena. Students go to college to demonstrate to future employers that they are diligent, can follow directions, and have invested more in their careers than other people. There is relatively little human capital appreciation through college--it is mostly a zero-sum signaling game. Students pay a very high cost, investing years and tens of thousands of dollars just to show that their signal is better than some other students. Students and society are losers, while colleges and employers reap the benefits. (I think Tyler Cowan effectively rebuts the argument here.)
Closer to my view is Glenn Reynolds, of Instapundit. He keeps talking about the higher education bubble, though it's not immediately clear what that means. It sounds like college is a house of cards, ready to fall apart. But the revolutionary zeal is largely absent from his book, which mostly suggests some rather modest changes around the edges--certainly nothing as dramatic or on as short a time frame as I have proposed.
Mr. Caplan's pessimistic conclusion is that higher ed, however dysfunctional, is nevertheless stable and will not change quickly. We're stuck with the girl that brung us. Thus he disagrees with all the bubble/crisis talk, and won't find my ten-year deadline credible. He'd say I live in the land of wishful thinking.
Back when I was an 18-year-old Trotskyist, in response to questions about the timing of the world revolution, we answered "maybe twenty years from now." For me that was more than a lifetime--a very long time away. Our thesis was that, because of new technology, history was speeding up--we could expect change faster than before. Today it seems hopelessly unrealistic--if anything, now forty years later, the revolution is even further away than it ever was.
So I could be a wishful thinker, but I'll stick to my ten-year prediction for these reasons. First, colleges are already under significant stress, with increasing pressure to lower prices and costs. Second, however relevant the curriculum may have been in the 1990s and before, it is much less useful today. I'm thinking of the general chemistry class I teach--it made students employable back then, but much less so today. And third, there simply is more competition than before. Students just have more choices.
When do these incremental changes reach a tipping point and disrupt the whole system? Will MOOCs be the straw that breaks the camel's back? Will it result from the unbundling implicit in the accreditation of individual courses? I don't know. Tipping points are notoriously hard to predict.
But here I stand: college will tip over sometime within the next nine years, eleven months, and 29 days. And good riddance!
Further Reading:
Sunday, October 6, 2013
Take A Trotskyist To Tea
The opening sentence of Jeff Mackler's article in Socialist Action displays all the faults of Leftist thinking.
The Tea Party understands this. We believe that government is an expense, not a benefit. Prisons, police departments, firemen, welfare social workers, tax collectors, soldiers and spies all cost money. They may be a necessary expense--I wouldn't want to live in a world without policemen, public streets, or parks--but they create no wealth.
Workers create wealth when they produce quality products at affordable prices that consumers want to buy. I can buy a car from honorable people like Gregg Shotwell or Diane Feeley but I can't buy a public street, a welfare case load, or the 5th Armored Division. Accordingly, we Tea Party types are pretty sanguine about the government shutdown. In particular, if non-essential government employees are laid off, so much the better. Why are we hiring non-essential employees in the first place?
Mr. Mackler cites an example of economic progress as if it were a great evil. About the newly booming American textile industry he writes
When American capitalism fails to make us all richer, Mr. Mackler calls that a crisis, and perhaps rightly so. But his solution is odd--he proposes instead that we go the full North Korea. Now it is true--North Korea has no economic crises, mostly because it has no economy. Their goal, far from making everybody richer, is to maximize poverty. That's a completely different goal from that most Americans share.
David Finkel, over at Solidarity, publishes an article with an extended update entitled Is the Ship of State Headed for a Shutdown? This gets into the weeds about the shenanigans in Congress in a way that smacks of reformism. Instead of demanding the full North Korea, Mr. Finkel is simply asking that the government stay open so that people can continue to receive benefits. In other words, he's sane.
The downside of sanity is that the article no longer reads like a Trotskyist wrote it. Instead it comes across as just another Progressive point of view, very similar to what you'd read in The Nation or In These Times. It's boring. And like those journals, he takes swipes at the Tea Party.
Here are some examples:
All political movements are tribal to some degree. Sharing the same political platform implies speaking the same language and sharing the same culture. American whites and Blacks are different tribes and therefore belong to separate political parties. This is similar to English and French Canadians or Muslim and Hindu Indians, etc. So I can agree with Redchuck4 about the ethnic and "class" characterization of the Tea Party, though I'd probably phrase it a bit differently. But that doesn't mean that we're racist any more than the fact that 90% of Blacks vote Democratic means that they're racist.
The Tea Party is not about racial purity. Instead it is a radical Libertarian group. In the cause of Liberty, we believe in limited government and Constitutional order. Congress (and hence the federal government) deserves no more power than that delimited by the Constitution. The extension of the federal government into things like health care is very much against the spirit of the Constitution, John Roberts' messy compromise notwithstanding. In our federal system the states are sovereign, and if government has a role in health care (a separate debate), then it has to come from the states.
Though few Blacks are members of the Tea Party, those that are have played a very important role. Two of our leading theoreticians, Thomas Sowell and Walter Williams, are African-American. Tea Partiers have adopted Martin Luther King as one of their own (see here). And all of us thrilled to the message of Herman Cain, who used the beautiful, eloquent and musical language of his culture in the cause of Liberty. I actually contributed money to his campaign, and was sorely disappointed when he turned out to be a deeply flawed candidate. There is the more recent example of Paul McKinley.
Indeed, cultural barriers notwithstanding, African-Americans should be the strongest supporters of the Tea Party. Who has suffered more from government tyranny than they? Who benefits more from strict equality under the law? Who suffers most from absurd nanny-state regulations that make many Black occupations illegal? (E.g., it's illegal to operate a Jitney cab without a city license, or braid hair without a beautician's diploma.)
So if you believe in Liberty, join us. And then, please invite a Trotskyist out for a cup of tea.
Further Reading:
In the old days—very old days like the last Great Depression of 1929—most people understood the term “economic stimulus” to mean some form of government investment in the economy aimed at directly producing jobs for working people through various kinds of public works programs.He actually believes that government make-work programs create jobs. They do nothing of the sort--all they do is redistribute the jobs from one place to another. Robbing Peter to pay Paul does make Paul richer, but it makes Peter poorer. Taxing money away from thriving businesses to pay for corrupt, politically-inspired, welfare projects makes society poorer.
The Tea Party understands this. We believe that government is an expense, not a benefit. Prisons, police departments, firemen, welfare social workers, tax collectors, soldiers and spies all cost money. They may be a necessary expense--I wouldn't want to live in a world without policemen, public streets, or parks--but they create no wealth.
Workers create wealth when they produce quality products at affordable prices that consumers want to buy. I can buy a car from honorable people like Gregg Shotwell or Diane Feeley but I can't buy a public street, a welfare case load, or the 5th Armored Division. Accordingly, we Tea Party types are pretty sanguine about the government shutdown. In particular, if non-essential government employees are laid off, so much the better. Why are we hiring non-essential employees in the first place?
Mr. Mackler cites an example of economic progress as if it were a great evil. About the newly booming American textile industry he writes
“This wasn’t some patriotic quest,” [textile CEO] Winthrop insisted. And indeed it wasn’t. Like all capitalists his loyalty was to the dollar, not to the working class. In addition to the savings in transportation costs, the turnaround time, and other technical matters, what interested this capitalist the most was the fact that, according to the The Times, “wages aren’t that much more overseas.”Mr. Mackler doesn't understand that the savings are sought to compete with rivals, and therefore to lower prices for consumers. The extra money will not be pocketed as additional profit for Mr. Winthrop. Instead it makes us all richer.
When American capitalism fails to make us all richer, Mr. Mackler calls that a crisis, and perhaps rightly so. But his solution is odd--he proposes instead that we go the full North Korea. Now it is true--North Korea has no economic crises, mostly because it has no economy. Their goal, far from making everybody richer, is to maximize poverty. That's a completely different goal from that most Americans share.
David Finkel, over at Solidarity, publishes an article with an extended update entitled Is the Ship of State Headed for a Shutdown? This gets into the weeds about the shenanigans in Congress in a way that smacks of reformism. Instead of demanding the full North Korea, Mr. Finkel is simply asking that the government stay open so that people can continue to receive benefits. In other words, he's sane.
The downside of sanity is that the article no longer reads like a Trotskyist wrote it. Instead it comes across as just another Progressive point of view, very similar to what you'd read in The Nation or In These Times. It's boring. And like those journals, he takes swipes at the Tea Party.
Here are some examples:
Defunding “Obamacare” or delaying it a year (a delay which could obviously be repeated over and over) would cripple the Obama presidency beyond hope of repair. That’s precisely why the racist-fuelled Tea Party is forcing the issue, and why the Democrats cannot give in even if they’re ready to viciously slash Social Security and Medicare for decades to come.And,
The Tea Party was largely created by a section of the ruling elite--the billionaire Koch brothers and the like--for this purpose, exploiting the paranoia and racism among white Americans as leverage against the Obama presidency.A commenter with the handle Redchuck4 (yes, unlike other Trotskyists, Solidarity allows comments) takes issue with Mr. Finkel, remarking that
The Tea Party, while supported by political outliers in the capitalist class like the Koch brothers, is a political phenomena that is INDEPENDENT of capital. It reflects the growing racist/nativist, anti-working class hysteria of sections of the white middle class-- both professionals and managers and small business people. Again, while capital may find these yahoos useful in their battle against working people at home and abroad, the Tea Party has and is often on capital's "wrong-side."Now I consider the accusation racist to be a slander--it's just an epithet. But lets take it seriously for a minute and see where it gets us.
All political movements are tribal to some degree. Sharing the same political platform implies speaking the same language and sharing the same culture. American whites and Blacks are different tribes and therefore belong to separate political parties. This is similar to English and French Canadians or Muslim and Hindu Indians, etc. So I can agree with Redchuck4 about the ethnic and "class" characterization of the Tea Party, though I'd probably phrase it a bit differently. But that doesn't mean that we're racist any more than the fact that 90% of Blacks vote Democratic means that they're racist.
The Tea Party is not about racial purity. Instead it is a radical Libertarian group. In the cause of Liberty, we believe in limited government and Constitutional order. Congress (and hence the federal government) deserves no more power than that delimited by the Constitution. The extension of the federal government into things like health care is very much against the spirit of the Constitution, John Roberts' messy compromise notwithstanding. In our federal system the states are sovereign, and if government has a role in health care (a separate debate), then it has to come from the states.
Though few Blacks are members of the Tea Party, those that are have played a very important role. Two of our leading theoreticians, Thomas Sowell and Walter Williams, are African-American. Tea Partiers have adopted Martin Luther King as one of their own (see here). And all of us thrilled to the message of Herman Cain, who used the beautiful, eloquent and musical language of his culture in the cause of Liberty. I actually contributed money to his campaign, and was sorely disappointed when he turned out to be a deeply flawed candidate. There is the more recent example of Paul McKinley.
Indeed, cultural barriers notwithstanding, African-Americans should be the strongest supporters of the Tea Party. Who has suffered more from government tyranny than they? Who benefits more from strict equality under the law? Who suffers most from absurd nanny-state regulations that make many Black occupations illegal? (E.g., it's illegal to operate a Jitney cab without a city license, or braid hair without a beautician's diploma.)
So if you believe in Liberty, join us. And then, please invite a Trotskyist out for a cup of tea.
Further Reading:
Sunday, September 29, 2013
Labor's Final Step
It's not often that one witnesses the end of a social movement--usually they just gradually fade away. But perhaps we have just seen the end of the trade union movement. The AFL-CIO convention held September 8th through 11th may represent the swan song.
And indeed, contradictions abound. The unions are terrified of Obamacare (aka ACA). Mr. Early writes
Unmentioned in any of the articles is the growing gap between the public employee unions (PEU) and those in the private sector. Just yesterday the Wall Street Journal posted an article saying how Governor Chris Christie has divided New Jersey's PEUs from the construction trade unions. The former can't stand the governor, while the latter are rallying to his cause.
A similar chasm exists between the Laborers International Union of North America (LIUNA) and those solidarity partners in the environmentalist movement. The latter oppose the Keystone pipeline, whereas LIUNA strongly favors it. Likewise, alt-Labor is against anything that might produce income: fracking, mining, off-shore drilling, power generation, and on and on and on. The progressive Left (including Trotskyism) is ultimately pro-poverty, while unionists are actually interested in earning an honest living.
Then there is the effort to "organize" the unorganized--fast food workers, New York taxi drivers, Walmart, etc. Ms. Lamont describes it nicely:
All three authors take the unions to task for not organizing more workers. They attribute this failure to class collaboration. Quoting again from Ms. Lamont:
The truth is that there is no longer any economic space for unions. Fast food workers can't earn enough to pay union dues, and it is certainly not in their interest to have that expense foisted on them. And likewise for Walmart employees, or, for that matter, auto workers in the South. Unions depended on inefficiencies during the rapidly growing economy of the 1950s and 1960s, from which they collected rents. Those inefficiencies don't exist anymore.
Computerization, globalization, and automation have made the economy much more efficient--there are no more wasted nickels left to pick up off the floor. But the money doesn't go to capitalists. No, instead it goes to the consumer. There is no stash of cash, and there is nothing for the unions to win, even with biggest temper tantrum in the world.
The AFL-CIO has apparently recognized reality and thrown in the towel on organizing workers. They're looking for a new niche.
The union movement is over.
Further Reading:
Trotskyists are all atwitter about the event, with lead articles appearing in The Militant, Socialist Action, and Solidarity. Missing from the list are Socialist Viewpoint, which has too slow a publication cycle, and Mr. Proyect, who (to his credit) has been busy covering Syria, and is not interested in economics in any case.
The best-written, most informed, and funniest article appears in Solidarity, by Steve Early. A former leader of the Communications Workers of America, he is now involved in a reform effort known as Labor Notes. Socialist Action's contribution is also good, authored by Bill Onasch. Mr. Onasch is the proprietor and (as far as I can tell) the sole member of the Kansas City Labor Party. Finally, The Militant chimes in with a piece by the venerable Susan Lamont.
The signal event is succinctly summarized by Ms. Lamont in her lede:
Marking a further retreat by the current labor officialdom from any perspective of actively organizing workers into unions and bringing union power to bear, delegates to the Sept. 8-11 AFL-CIO convention overwhelmingly approved a resolution to begin incorporating nonlabor political organizations into the federation and shoring up its dues base with “workers centers.”
The labor movement can’t be “limited to workplaces where a majority of employees votes 'Yes,” said the resolution....
Liberal political organizations that share the labor federation’s orientation to the Democratic Party, including the NAACP, National Organization for Women, National Council of La Raza and the Sierra Club, are invited to join the labor federation as well.Or, put another way, the AFL-CIO is dissolving itself into the larger progressive Left. Right now the outside organizations are called Solidarity Partners. Mr. Early dubs them alt-Labor. All three authors argue that this dilutes both the purpose and the effectiveness of unions as organizations charged with fighting for workers' rights.
And indeed, contradictions abound. The unions are terrified of Obamacare (aka ACA). Mr. Early writes
With the AFL-CIO’s active support, the Obama Administration came up with an Affordable Care Act that now threatens to put labor-backed Taft-Hartley trust funds, covering 20 million people, at a fatal disadvantage and possibly out of business altogether.On a similar note, Mr. Onasch notes that the Labor Campaign for Single Payer Healthcare received a tepid welcome at the convention--if anything can put union benefit packages out of business faster than Obamacare, it would be something like single payer. So unlike their Solidarity Partners, the AFL-CIO finds itself allied with Republicans (very ironic since they originally supported the ACA).
Unmentioned in any of the articles is the growing gap between the public employee unions (PEU) and those in the private sector. Just yesterday the Wall Street Journal posted an article saying how Governor Chris Christie has divided New Jersey's PEUs from the construction trade unions. The former can't stand the governor, while the latter are rallying to his cause.
"My guys haven't gotten a raise in two years because their entire raise went to their health and pension costs," Mr. Sweeney said. "New Jersey has a government that we can't afford any longer."Mr. Sweeney, a former Ironworkers official, is now a Democratic state legislator. So the rank and file rubes are finally catching on--that it's them who are paying for the gold-plated benefits packages awarded to the parasite class. The AFL-CIO is going to have a hard time patching up this divide.
A similar chasm exists between the Laborers International Union of North America (LIUNA) and those solidarity partners in the environmentalist movement. The latter oppose the Keystone pipeline, whereas LIUNA strongly favors it. Likewise, alt-Labor is against anything that might produce income: fracking, mining, off-shore drilling, power generation, and on and on and on. The progressive Left (including Trotskyism) is ultimately pro-poverty, while unionists are actually interested in earning an honest living.
Then there is the effort to "organize" the unorganized--fast food workers, New York taxi drivers, Walmart, etc. Ms. Lamont describes it nicely:
The AFL-CIO will encourage “worker centers” like “OUR Walmart” and “Fight for 15” to affiliate. These union-initiated groups, which also involve students, social service organization staffers and others, have organized protests around the country calling for higher pay and better working conditions for retail, fast-food and other workers, but without organizing the ranks themselves to establish actual unions.She implicitly admits that the so-called "fast-food strike" was a bit of a fraud--most of the strikers didn't work in fast food. And similarly for the putative drive to organize Walmart.
All three authors take the unions to task for not organizing more workers. They attribute this failure to class collaboration. Quoting again from Ms. Lamont:
By promoting class collaboration with the bosses and election of “friendly” capitalist politicians as the unions’ main purpose, the officialdom’s decades-long class-collaborationist course has hamstrung the union movement. It has been key to the union’s continued bleeding of membership and inability to recruit new forces, at a time of capitalist crisis when workers are starting to look for a way to fight back.Mr. Onasch says the same thing, and then offers a solution:
The problem created by those in charge of the House of Labor is not their emphasis on politics but their refusal to recognize the need for class-based politics. Our side should be directly fighting for political power, not begging or bribing politicians beholden to our class enemy. There is no more important question for the American working class today than launching a party of our own. Despite their present weakness and disorientation, our unions, and the allies they now solicit, are the foundation upon which such a party can be built.These views don't pass the reality test. They are based on the Scrooge McDuck Model of Capitalism, which claims that there's some huge stash of cash hidden somewhere that, if the workers just throw a big enough temper tantrum, can be liberated to solve all problems. But there is no such stash, and the union tops know that. They're doing the best they can with the resources available.
The truth is that there is no longer any economic space for unions. Fast food workers can't earn enough to pay union dues, and it is certainly not in their interest to have that expense foisted on them. And likewise for Walmart employees, or, for that matter, auto workers in the South. Unions depended on inefficiencies during the rapidly growing economy of the 1950s and 1960s, from which they collected rents. Those inefficiencies don't exist anymore.
Computerization, globalization, and automation have made the economy much more efficient--there are no more wasted nickels left to pick up off the floor. But the money doesn't go to capitalists. No, instead it goes to the consumer. There is no stash of cash, and there is nothing for the unions to win, even with biggest temper tantrum in the world.
The AFL-CIO has apparently recognized reality and thrown in the towel on organizing workers. They're looking for a new niche.
The union movement is over.
Further Reading:
Saturday, September 21, 2013
George Gilder, Evolution, & Science
This post started life as a review of George Gilder's recent book, Knowledge and Power. But the book is unreviewable, at least in a short post. Don't get me wrong--it's a fabulous read. Mr. Gilder is a superb writer, very literate, extraordinarily entertaining, and there is a surprise on almost every page (that last being a compliment Mr. Gilder will especially appreciate). However, it is nothing if not complicated, and the author promiscuously crosses and re-crosses that fine line between visionary and crackpot. Parsing it all apart is a task beyond me.
When one goes through a dramatic change in world view--as I did in my transition from Trotskyist to Republican--certain books become very influential. First for me was Milton Friedman's Capitalism and Freedom. Second place is a longer list, including two by Mr. Gilder--Wealth and Poverty and Men and Marriage. The former was the first serious book about economics I ever read, and it inspired a life-long interest. Even today, were Mr. Gilder to read this blog, I doubt there is much about economics where he would disagree. I also read Microcosm, a book that I thought was silly.
I subsequently learned that Mr. Gilder is co-founder of the Discovery Institute, an organization I associated with know-nothing religious objections to evolution. (These days I argue against the know-nothing Marxist objections, which are actually nearly the same thing.) So I approached the current tome with trepidation.
It's mostly about economics, and indeed he makes the strongest case for capitalism I have ever read. He borrows from Claude Shannon's information theory, and the analogy to economics is enlightening and convincing. But beyond economics, he proposes information theory as a theory of everything (my term), employing it, at one point, even to dispute the second law of thermodynamics. The subplot of the book is a philosophy of science, and a sub-subplot of that concerns Darwinism. Specifically, he takes issue with Daniel Dennett's book Darwin's Dangerous Idea. Dennett extends Darwinism to memes and elevates that to a theory of everything. He calls natural selection "the universal solvent," i.e., everything (literally) is just a series of selected, random permutations.
Astonishingly, I agree with Mr. Gilder in this dispute, despite being an avid a fan of Darwinism. I do not think Darwinism is a theory of everything. As a unifying concept in biology it is absolutely compelling. Insofar as human beings are biological critters, evolution rules. Both religious and Marxist objections that evolution somehow stopped the instant humans came along is completely wrong. Evolutionary psychology is indisputably a valid approach to understanding human instinct and much of human behavior.
But Mr. Gilder correctly notes that evolution cannot account for new technology. While our sexual, culinary, social, and child-rearing urges likely have biological roots, there is no way that the invention of a jet aircraft or an iPad can be predicted by evolutionary psychology. Simple-minded reductionism will not do--some other factor comes into play.
Mr. Gilder falls into the trap of saying that science only describes the material world, and that the extra-scientific world of ideas must also be considered. (This oddly echos Marxist complaints about idealism. It also revisits the similar debate around the turn of the last century between Ludwig Boltzmann and Ernst Mach.) In this he disagrees with authors like Stephen Pinker and Steven Landsburg, who come down strongly on the "materialist" side, contending that people don't have free will. Mr. Landsburg even makes the silly argument that (since mental processing is obviously done in parallel) because we begin muscle movements milliseconds before we're aware of them, therefore free will is a myth. (I can plan things months in advance, but never mind.)
I personally reject the material-ideal distinction. My working definition of science is this: Science is the study of reproducible phenomena. Reproducible means that all normal human beings perceive the phenomena in ways that they describe similarly. Normal people will see a red book and a red table and verify between themselves that they are the same color. Normal in this case does not include folks who are colorblind (or just plain blind). Nor does it include cats, which even if they were intelligent enough to communicate with us, have a completely different visual physiology and don't see things the same way. Reproducibility is common at the level of human perception (which is why arguments that science is merely a cultural artifact fall flat with me).
All normal human beings have a sense of free will, normal in this case excluding small children and schizophrenics. The phenomenon is as reproducible as the color red. Therefore when people like Pinker and Landsburg say we have no free will, they are just flat-out wrong. Of course we do.
Though that's not the end of the story. Color perception, for example, depends as much or more on eye and brain physiology than it does on the science of optics (Google the word metamer for more information). One could very reasonably argue that our color sense is just an illusion--the colors aren't really there. That's the kind of argument that Messrs. Pinker and Landsburg make for free will. But it's ultimately solipsistic--since all perception depends on physiological states, then one can't believe any of it. Everything is an illusion.
So it's true that free will, like color perception, requires explanation and elaboration. It clearly has something to do with brain physiology. But that doesn't make it less real. It may be that free will is an epiphenomenon of evolution, or perhaps an emergent phenomenon, or something else altogether. But it is very unlikely that it can be satisfactorily described by evolutionary psychology. There is some other constituent--call it a soul if you want--to the human being that exists beyond Darwinism.
Many, possibly including Mr. Gilder, argue that the soul exists independently of the brain, perhaps even out-living the brain. There is no reproducible evidence for this--millennia of seances, ancestor worship, praying to the saints, ghost stories, etc., have yielded no consensus among normal people. The scientific conclusion, therefore, is that the soul and brain are inextricably linked. I, for one, have no trouble with the fundamental assumption of neuroscience--that for every mental state there corresponds a physical state. But the direction of the causal arrow is not determined. Of course changing the physical state--seeing a big truck while standing in the middle of the road--will alter my mental state. But free will implies that the causal arrow goes the other way as well, and it most assuredly does.
Mr. Pinker argues against the ghost in the machine, i.e., against the existence of scientifically unsupported, irreproducible causes of mental states. In this he is certainly correct. But he counterposes a rigid, Newtonian determinism, for which there is also no scientific evidence. There is a huge gap between those two poles. There is no ghost in the machine, but free will is also not a straightforward product of physics or evolution. There is, instead, a third way. Looking for emergent phenomena might be a place to start.
In my dreams I imagine that some comrade some day will read this blog and say "Aha! Marxism is wrong. I'm going to be a Republican." If it ever does happen, it won't be because of evolutionary psychology.
Further Reading:
When one goes through a dramatic change in world view--as I did in my transition from Trotskyist to Republican--certain books become very influential. First for me was Milton Friedman's Capitalism and Freedom. Second place is a longer list, including two by Mr. Gilder--Wealth and Poverty and Men and Marriage. The former was the first serious book about economics I ever read, and it inspired a life-long interest. Even today, were Mr. Gilder to read this blog, I doubt there is much about economics where he would disagree. I also read Microcosm, a book that I thought was silly.
I subsequently learned that Mr. Gilder is co-founder of the Discovery Institute, an organization I associated with know-nothing religious objections to evolution. (These days I argue against the know-nothing Marxist objections, which are actually nearly the same thing.) So I approached the current tome with trepidation.
It's mostly about economics, and indeed he makes the strongest case for capitalism I have ever read. He borrows from Claude Shannon's information theory, and the analogy to economics is enlightening and convincing. But beyond economics, he proposes information theory as a theory of everything (my term), employing it, at one point, even to dispute the second law of thermodynamics. The subplot of the book is a philosophy of science, and a sub-subplot of that concerns Darwinism. Specifically, he takes issue with Daniel Dennett's book Darwin's Dangerous Idea. Dennett extends Darwinism to memes and elevates that to a theory of everything. He calls natural selection "the universal solvent," i.e., everything (literally) is just a series of selected, random permutations.
Astonishingly, I agree with Mr. Gilder in this dispute, despite being an avid a fan of Darwinism. I do not think Darwinism is a theory of everything. As a unifying concept in biology it is absolutely compelling. Insofar as human beings are biological critters, evolution rules. Both religious and Marxist objections that evolution somehow stopped the instant humans came along is completely wrong. Evolutionary psychology is indisputably a valid approach to understanding human instinct and much of human behavior.
But Mr. Gilder correctly notes that evolution cannot account for new technology. While our sexual, culinary, social, and child-rearing urges likely have biological roots, there is no way that the invention of a jet aircraft or an iPad can be predicted by evolutionary psychology. Simple-minded reductionism will not do--some other factor comes into play.
Mr. Gilder falls into the trap of saying that science only describes the material world, and that the extra-scientific world of ideas must also be considered. (This oddly echos Marxist complaints about idealism. It also revisits the similar debate around the turn of the last century between Ludwig Boltzmann and Ernst Mach.) In this he disagrees with authors like Stephen Pinker and Steven Landsburg, who come down strongly on the "materialist" side, contending that people don't have free will. Mr. Landsburg even makes the silly argument that (since mental processing is obviously done in parallel) because we begin muscle movements milliseconds before we're aware of them, therefore free will is a myth. (I can plan things months in advance, but never mind.)
I personally reject the material-ideal distinction. My working definition of science is this: Science is the study of reproducible phenomena. Reproducible means that all normal human beings perceive the phenomena in ways that they describe similarly. Normal people will see a red book and a red table and verify between themselves that they are the same color. Normal in this case does not include folks who are colorblind (or just plain blind). Nor does it include cats, which even if they were intelligent enough to communicate with us, have a completely different visual physiology and don't see things the same way. Reproducibility is common at the level of human perception (which is why arguments that science is merely a cultural artifact fall flat with me).
All normal human beings have a sense of free will, normal in this case excluding small children and schizophrenics. The phenomenon is as reproducible as the color red. Therefore when people like Pinker and Landsburg say we have no free will, they are just flat-out wrong. Of course we do.
Though that's not the end of the story. Color perception, for example, depends as much or more on eye and brain physiology than it does on the science of optics (Google the word metamer for more information). One could very reasonably argue that our color sense is just an illusion--the colors aren't really there. That's the kind of argument that Messrs. Pinker and Landsburg make for free will. But it's ultimately solipsistic--since all perception depends on physiological states, then one can't believe any of it. Everything is an illusion.
So it's true that free will, like color perception, requires explanation and elaboration. It clearly has something to do with brain physiology. But that doesn't make it less real. It may be that free will is an epiphenomenon of evolution, or perhaps an emergent phenomenon, or something else altogether. But it is very unlikely that it can be satisfactorily described by evolutionary psychology. There is some other constituent--call it a soul if you want--to the human being that exists beyond Darwinism.
Many, possibly including Mr. Gilder, argue that the soul exists independently of the brain, perhaps even out-living the brain. There is no reproducible evidence for this--millennia of seances, ancestor worship, praying to the saints, ghost stories, etc., have yielded no consensus among normal people. The scientific conclusion, therefore, is that the soul and brain are inextricably linked. I, for one, have no trouble with the fundamental assumption of neuroscience--that for every mental state there corresponds a physical state. But the direction of the causal arrow is not determined. Of course changing the physical state--seeing a big truck while standing in the middle of the road--will alter my mental state. But free will implies that the causal arrow goes the other way as well, and it most assuredly does.
Mr. Pinker argues against the ghost in the machine, i.e., against the existence of scientifically unsupported, irreproducible causes of mental states. In this he is certainly correct. But he counterposes a rigid, Newtonian determinism, for which there is also no scientific evidence. There is a huge gap between those two poles. There is no ghost in the machine, but free will is also not a straightforward product of physics or evolution. There is, instead, a third way. Looking for emergent phenomena might be a place to start.
In my dreams I imagine that some comrade some day will read this blog and say "Aha! Marxism is wrong. I'm going to be a Republican." If it ever does happen, it won't be because of evolutionary psychology.
Further Reading:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)